No Stone on X-ray, Yet This Dog Couldn’t Urinate. Why Was Surgery Necessary?
Not every urinary obstruction is caused by a large, visible bladder stone. Sometimes, the underlying problem involves microscopic crystals and urinary sediment that cannot be adequately identified through conventional radiography alone.
For a 4-year-old male Chihuahua brought to Aycardo Veterinary Center Inc. (AVCI), what initially appeared to be difficulty urinating progressed into a complete urinary obstruction requiring surgical intervention.
The case highlights the importance of comprehensive diagnostic evaluation and the role of scrotal urethrostomy, a surgical procedure designed to establish a permanent alternative opening for urine to leave the body when conventional urinary drainage cannot be restored.
From Difficulty Urinating to Complete Obstruction
The patient initially presented with dysuria, the medical term for difficult or painful urination, accompanied by urinary spotting and the passage of only small amounts of urine.
Over the following two days, the condition progressed to a complete inability to urinate, indicating a potentially life-threatening urethral obstruction.
The urethra is the narrow tubular passage responsible for transporting urine from the urinary bladder to the outside of the body. When this passage becomes blocked, urine accumulates in the bladder, increasing pressure within the urinary tract.
If the obstruction persists, complications may include bladder overdistension, impaired kidney function, electrolyte disturbances, and potentially life-threatening systemic complications.
Initial attempts were made to relieve the obstruction through urinary catheterization, a procedure in which a flexible tube is introduced into the urethra to establish urinary drainage.
However, five catheterization attempts over approximately 24 hours were unsuccessful because the catheter could not be advanced beyond the obstructed segment.
With conventional catheterization unsuccessful, surgical intervention became necessary to establish an alternative route for urine drainage.
Diagnostic Findings: When the X-ray Does Not Reveal the Entire Problem
Interestingly, abdominal radiographs did not reveal obvious urinary calculi, commonly known as urinary stones.
However, the absence of visible stones on X-ray does not exclude urinary obstruction.
Some urinary stones, including those composed of cystine, have relatively low radiographic visibility and may be difficult to detect using conventional X-rays.
Further diagnostic investigation provided additional information.
Urinalysis and Urine Sediment Examination
Although the initial routine urinalysis did not identify significant crystal formation, subsequent microscopic examination of urine collected through cystocentesis revealed numerous characteristic cystine crystals.
Cystocentesis is a diagnostic procedure in which a urine sample is collected directly from the urinary bladder using a sterile needle, commonly with ultrasound guidance.
The presence of cystine crystals supported cystine crystalluria, a condition characterized by the precipitation of cystine within the urine.
These findings raised suspicion of cystinuria, a disorder involving impaired renal tubular reabsorption of certain amino acids, particularly cystine.
Normally, the kidneys filter and subsequently reabsorb much of the cystine present in the bloodstream. In dogs affected by cystinuria, excessive cystine may be excreted into the urine.
Because cystine has limited solubility, especially under certain urinary conditions, it can precipitate into crystals and potentially form urinary stones.
Ultrasonographic Examination
Abdominal ultrasonography revealed abundant echogenic, fine particulate material suspended within the urinary bladder.
These dust-like echoes suggested substantial urinary sediment, consistent with the crystalluria identified during microscopic examination.
Mild prostatic enlargement, consistent with benign prostatic hyperplasia, was also identified.
Taken together, the clinical findings, failed catheterization, urinary sediment examination, and diagnostic imaging supported urethral obstruction associated with cystine crystalluria and suspected underlying cystinuria.
Surgical Intervention: Scrotal Urethrostomy
Because the urinary obstruction could not be relieved through catheterization, the veterinary team proceeded with a scrotal urethrostomy.
This procedure creates a permanent alternative urinary opening in the scrotal region, allowing urine to exit through a wider segment of the urethra.
Why Is the Scrotal Region Used?
In male dogs, the urethra becomes particularly narrow as it passes through the region of the os penis, a bone located within the penis.
This anatomical narrowing makes the distal urethra a common location where urinary calculi or other obstructive material may become lodged.
The urethra in the scrotal region is comparatively wider and more accessible surgically.
By establishing a new opening at this location, urine can bypass the narrower distal portion of the urethra, reducing the likelihood of recurrent obstruction at that segment.
How Does Scrotal Urethrostomy Work?
During this surgical procedure, the veterinarian accesses the urethra in the scrotal region and creates an opening through its wall.
The urethral mucosa—the specialized tissue lining the inside of the urethra—is surgically joined to the surrounding skin to form a permanent opening called a urethrostomy stoma.
This new opening allows urine to exit directly from the wider scrotal segment of the urethra rather than traveling through the entire penile urethra.
The procedure is intended to:
• Establish an alternative route for urinary drainage when conventional catheterization cannot relieve the obstruction.
• Bypass the narrower distal urethra, where obstructive material may become trapped.
• Facilitate the passage of urine and smaller urinary particles or calculi.
• Reduce the risk of recurrent obstruction involving the bypassed urethral segment.
Importantly, scrotal urethrostomy does not eliminate the underlying metabolic tendency to form cystine crystals or stones. Continued management remains necessary because urinary abnormalities may persist even after successful surgery.
Why Was Castration Performed Concurrently?
Castration and scrotal removal were performed during the same surgical intervention.
In addition to facilitating the scrotal surgical approach, castration eliminates the primary source of testicular androgens, the hormones responsible for stimulating certain reproductive tissues.
This was particularly relevant because the patient also exhibited mild benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH), a noncancerous enlargement of the prostate commonly associated with androgen stimulation in intact male dogs.
Castration can promote regression of androgen-dependent prostatic enlargement.
Furthermore, some forms of canine cystinuria are androgen-dependent, meaning their severity may decrease following castration. However, this response varies according to the underlying type of cystinuria.
Postoperative Monitoring and Recovery
Following surgery, the patient remained hospitalized for close monitoring of urinary function, surgical healing, and overall clinical stability.
The postoperative period required additional medical management after the development of bleeding and hematological abnormalities.
Laboratory monitoring identified anemia, reflected by a decrease in packed cell volume (PCV) to below 20%, together with a prolonged activated clotting time (ACT).
PCV represents the proportion of blood occupied by red blood cells, while ACT is a laboratory test used to assess certain components of blood coagulation.
The clinical findings raised concern about impaired hemostasis, the physiological process responsible for stopping bleeding.
A possible contribution from the prescribed nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) was suspected. Following discontinuation of the medication and continued supportive management, bleeding was controlled and coagulation parameters gradually improved.
The patient received additional supportive treatment and continued monitoring throughout hospitalization.
After approximately 11 days of hospitalization, the patient was clinically stable, although some blood parameters had not yet fully normalized.
By approximately 20 days after the initial hospitalization, the patient’s hematological findings and overall clinical condition had improved toward normal levels.
Managing the Risk of Future Urinary Obstruction
Although the surgery addressed the immediate problem of urinary drainage, ongoing management remained important because of the patient’s suspected underlying cystinuria.
The patient was subsequently transitioned to a veterinary therapeutic urinary diet intended to improve urinary conditions and reduce the risk of recurrent crystal formation.
Long-term management of cystine-associated urinary disease may involve dietary modification, appropriate hydration, urine pH management, and periodic laboratory monitoring, depending on the individual patient’s condition.
Follow-up examinations are also important for assessing the surgical opening and identifying complications such as inflammation, urinary tract infection, or stomal stenosis, a condition in which scar tissue causes narrowing of the surgically created urinary opening.
Even after scrotal urethrostomy, sufficiently large stones or obstructions located upstream from the new opening may still interfere with urinary drainage.
Therefore, surgery and continued medical management serve complementary purposes: one addresses the mechanical obstruction, while the other aims to reduce the risk of future urinary complications.
What Pet Owners Can Learn From This Case
This case illustrates how urinary obstruction can progress rapidly from difficulty urinating to a potentially life-threatening emergency.
It also demonstrates why an apparently normal X-ray does not necessarily rule out significant urinary disease.
By combining clinical assessment, microscopic urine examination, diagnostic imaging, and surgical intervention, the veterinary team was able to identify a likely underlying cause and establish an appropriate treatment approach.
For pet owners, repeated straining, passing only small amounts of urine, or an inability to urinate should always be treated as an urgent veterinary concern.
At AVCI, surgical care extends beyond the procedure itself. Appropriate case assessment, surgical planning, postoperative monitoring, and continued medical management are all important components of caring for patients with complex urinary conditions.
Because sometimes, restoring a pet’s ability to urinate requires more than medication—it requires a carefully planned surgical solution and continued veterinary care.
Case handled by Dr. Mon Constancio J. Gabutan.
Dr. Mon Constancio J. Gabutan
Attending Veterinarian

